Part 2. Expensive Laser Eye Surgery – Is It Worth It?

| Oct 19, 2008 | Comments 0

Following on from yesterdays post on some key LASIK and laser eye surgery questions, lets look at these:

  • Do clinics try to sell you on the most expensive treatments?
  • Are these expensive treatments no better than the cheaper ones?
  • Is there really any difference between blade LASIK and the newer (more expensive) blade free dual laser option?

The main point here is about more expensive laser eye treatments over cheaper ones. What is the difference?

When you buy anything you normally have a choice of quality and price, for example an HD television or more basic one. Or a Mercedes over a Fiat Punto. We all understand that more money usually gets a higher value brand and clinics typically price the surgery this way too.

There are two ways you can upgrade your treatment: (1) upgrading on the quality of the final vision (you will see better afterwards) and (2) improving the safety and accuracy of the eye surgery. These are upgrades on what used to be the best treatment only a few years ago, which is known as non-wavefront LASIK and using a blade device to cut a thin flap in the surface of the cornea (the clear window at the front of the eye).

Let’s look first at spending more to get better quality of vision than the older ‘standard’ treatments (which are STILL available at most clinics, not at my centre – FOCUS, by the way, although there is a good case to abandon this older technology). The high street chains (Ultralase, Optimax and Optical Express) all offer two levels of surgery for quality of vision.

The basic cheaper treatment is called by various names but all are what are termed ‘Non-Wavefront’ surgeries. For example Ultralase call it just ‘laser eye surgery’, Optimax and Optical Express refer just to ‘LASIK’.

The higher quality, better vision treatments all come under what is called ‘Wavefront’ laser eye surgery.

‘Wavefront’ simply refers to a technology that is claimed to offer higher-definition vision, especially at night time, which was introduced several years ago.

Just to confuse you there are different names, again depending on which clinic you visit! For example, Ultralase call this ‘ULTRALASIKplus‘, Optimax opt for the simpler ‘Wavefront LASIK‘, while Optical Express go for the mouthful of ‘Advanced CustomVue Wavefront LASIK‘. Other independent clinics use various names.

At my own clinic FOCUS Laser Vision, we only offer the higher quality vision ‘wavefront’ laser eye treatments. You cannot get non-wavefront eye surgery with us.

Please note that paying more at one clinic doesn’t mean you get better surgery than at another clinic. You need to look at what you are paying for. For example FOCUS Laser Vision charge less for advanced wavefront correction than most other clinics do for older technology non-wavefront treatments. Blowing my own trumpet here, I know! But paying more does not always equal getting more. More on this later.

Kay also asked in her mail about the ethics of treatment offerings and we will cover that topic in the next blog postings. Basically, is it ethical to offer lower quality treatments when newer higher quality ones are available? No-one cares about this for other products and services (is it ethical to sell Fiat Puntos when Mercedes are available?) but it can be a hot topic in healthcare. I will write on this subject during the coming week. And I will welcome your comments!

OK, but are these ‘wavefront’ treatments really better than ‘non-wavefront’? Come back tomorrow to get the truth!

»crosslinked«

Filed Under: Clinics • LASIK • Prices • Safety • Technology

Tags: • • • • • • • •

About the Author: Mr. Dave Allamby FRCS FRCOphth is a leading London-based laser eye surgeon. You may have seen him on the This Morning TV show with Phillip Schofield and Fern Britton or read one of several articles in the national press, recently for treating Denise Van Outen, rock giant Rick Wakeman and broadcaster Paul Ross. David is Medical Director at Focus Laser Vision, known as a world-leading clinic in the treatment of presbyopia, or age related loss of close vision. Focus Laser Vision is also London's only clinic to offer next-generation Z-LASIK laser eye treatment for short sight, long sight or astigmatism.

RSSComments (0)

Trackback URL

Leave a Reply

Rss Feed Technorati button Reddit button Myspace button Linkedin button Delicious button Digg button Stumbleupon button Flickr button Facebook button Tweeter button Youtube button